Resident Arses:


Alex


HoosierCon


Ragnar
« Looking for a New Sidearm... | Front page | My New Baby : a Springfield... »
Ragnar's Newest Addition?


Thanks for all the input. Based on the feedback, and other research I've done on the web, I'm planning to go with the Springfield Armory XD.

I'm pretty old school, and I've always had a soft spot in my heart for the classic Beretta/Taurus lines and the feel of a metal frame gun. That said, there are times when you just have to "step into the future," and this may be one of those times.

There's a gun show this weekend, and if I come across one of these at the right price, I may just have to pick one up.

Of course, there remains the age-old question: WHICH CALIBER? I'm leaning toward .40 S&W, but I'm open to being persuaded otherwise.

Thoughts?
By
Ragnar
  2008-02-22 20:09:59
by Gordon Marock  2008-02-23 08:26:26
Reply   permalink
Go with .45.
by stuart  2008-02-23 09:08:26
Reply   permalink
I've been looking at this as well along with the more expensive HK P2000sk. I favor the 9mm but Ive been looking for a compact 45 for a carry gun. The 45ACP XD is reportedly very inaccurate due to front sighting above 10 yards--you would expect to take it to a gunsmith for better sights.
by Randman  2008-02-23 09:19:14
Reply   permalink
The .40 is the way to go.
by Saint  2008-02-23 09:26:26
Reply   permalink
.45 if your going for protection. It'll drop a man regardless of the drugs he's using.
by OldTigerCub  2008-02-23 09:43:11
Reply   permalink
For availability and sheer stopping power, my choice is the .45ACP.
by MIles  2008-02-23 09:50:35
Reply   permalink
My brother has a 9mm Springfield Arms subcompact. Because of our stubby-fingered hands "fit for an axe, not a guitar" as my mom once said, the grip fit him much better.
by USCitizen  2008-02-23 12:30:36
Reply   permalink
Let me know if one of these meets your needs (1,754 XD's in 54 models of 40W
by usdesertdweller  2008-02-23 18:52:00
Reply   permalink
There isn't much size difference in the pistol, so go for stopping power with a .45ACP.

BTW, I own a 9mm Sig P226 and if I didn't already have that, I'd buy the SA-XD in 45ACP in a heartbeat.

As for cost, don't sweat that the XD is lower priced. It's a great gun. Just as accurate as the SIG, IMHO (they use the same type of lockup mechanism).
by Ragnar  2008-02-23 19:10:05
Reply   permalink
Works 4 me.
by Thomas  2008-02-24 19:12:53
Reply   permalink
My local gun dealer said that the Taurus company gives awful customer service and recommended Smith and Wesson instead. Just FYI.
by  anonymous (BFE)  2008-02-25 06:41:27
Reply   permalink
The XD is a good weapon. I'm a .45 guy myself - but I've run the gamit over the years. I still own 9's and a Glock .357 SIG. Never had a .40 - never saw any reason to. If I want more than a 9, I'll carry my .357 or my .45. I just don't get the point of a short 10mm - kinda like the .380 to me....
« Looking for a New Sidearm... | Front page | My New Baby : a Springfield... »